Neighbors Reject Ames St. Sunoco Filtration Buildings
The Board of Zoning Appeals requested representatives to go back to the drawing table to come up with new designs.
A Sunoco gas station at the corner of Bridge Street and Ames Street seeks a permit from the Zoning Board of Appeals to build two structures to help filter contaminated ground water, but residents spoke out against the plan last week.
Residents complained that the new structures would drag down the area’s aesthetic appeal, and they voices concerns about the noise of the filter’s engine.
Elie Rachmani, a Bridge Street resident, lives directly behind the gas station said, "My living room is 40 feet from where it’s going to be," and wanted to know if the sound would reach him.
Mike Decoteau, one of the environmental project managers from Groundwater and Environmental Service Inc. in Westford, Mass., said that there would be one 20 horsepower pump forcing the water through carbon to clean it and another to pump the filtered water into the town’s storm water system.
The station plans to construct a 8-foot-by-30-foot building that will house the filtration pump and the other will be a 8-by-20 that contains the pumping system that puts the water into the storm water system, said Brian Horan, also a project manager from Groundwater and Environmental Service. Currently a truck visits the site once a month to filter the groundwater, Horan said. At its current rate of filtration, it would take 50 years to filter the site completely. If they install these two pumps, it would take three to five years, he said.
One design for the buildings is similar in aesthetics to a large portable dumpster. Upon seeing it Rachmani said, "No one would want to look out their window and see that."
Horan then showed a design that looked similar to barn-style shed-like structure.
The board did not approve the permit. Jim McGrail, chairman of the Board of Zoning Appeals, said that he wanted an acoustical engineer and a landscape architect to be consulted before Horan and Decoteau made another presentation before the board.
In a statement to the Dedham Patch, Amy Blanchard, a public and government affairs advisor at ExxonMobil said the proposed filtration system is being sought because, "Station equipment upgrades were conducted prior to transferring property ownership. At that time, impacts to soil and groundwater were detected."
She added, "Groundwater and Environmental Services, on behalf of ExxonMobil Environmental Services Co., is working under the direction of the Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection as it performs an investigation. Presently, GES is also in discussions with the Town of Dedham Zoning Board regarding the possible installation of a remedial system at a former Mobil station on 19 Ames Street to address gasoline constituents detected in soil and groundwater. GES takes its environmental responsibilities seriously and will work with the local community as its investigation progresses".
RONALD C FERRARA
5:02 pm on Saturday, April 23, 2011
I LIVE AT THE CORNER OD AMES AND FISHER, MY HOME IS A STONES THROW TO THE SUNOCO GAS STATION AT 19 AMES STREET. I ATTENDED A MEETING BETWEEN RESIDENTS AND GES PERSONNEL. IWAS DISAPPOINTED IN THE RESULTS. THE NOISE LEVEL IS A CONCERN, 61 DECIBEL TO 71 DECIBELS WILL BE HEARD FOR A PERIOD OF 3 TO 5 YEARS 24 HOURS A DAY 7 DAYS A WEEK IS UNACCEPTABLE.WITH THE TECHNOLOGY PRESENT I FIND IT HARD TO BELIEVE THE NUMBER OF DECIBELS CAN' T BE REDUCED. THIS AREA IS VERY RESIDENTIAL AND THE PICTURES I SAW OF THE STRUCTURES TO BE PLACED ON THE SITE FOR THAT LENGTH OF TIME CAN BE VERY DISTRACTING. I UNDERSTAND A TRUCK COMES ONCE A MONTH TO PERFORM A CLEANING SERVICE AT THE SITE AND IF IT WERE TO CONTINUE IT WOULD TAKE 50 YEARS TO COMPLETE THE SERVICE, I HAVE NO PROBLEM WITH THAT TIME FRAME CONSIDERING WHAT WILL BE GOING ON FOR 3 TO 5 YEARS. I VISION PROPERTY VALUES DROPPING IN THE AREA. I AM THREE HOMES AWAY FROM THE PROPOSED SITE AND I AM NOT AND WAS NOT SATISFIES WITH THE RESULTSOF THE MEETING ON WEDNESDAY APRIL 20,2011. RONALD C. FERRARA 4 FISHER ROAD.